The definitive guide to local shopping; methodically researched, updated daily.

November 21, 2024

(707) 347-0333

  • See related categories in Columbus

  • Consumers use the Prime Buyer's Report to avoid the scam, fraud, and businesses with low customer satisfaction

    Independent research conducted by Prime Buyer's Report editors includes phone call surveys with customers of local businesses, checks with state agencies on license and complaint history, verification that each business has insurance coverage to protect you as a customer, phone interviews of business owners, signed agreements that they use only legal workers, and more to determine the businesses that are safe to spend with.

    See All The Research Steps

  • Jewelry Stores in Columbus serving Bexley, Canal Winchester, Columbus, Dublin, Gahanna, Grandview Heights, Grove City, Groveport, Hilliard, New Albany, Pickerington, Reynoldsburg, Upper Arlington, Westerville, Whitehall, Worthington, Obetz, Blendon, Clinton, Franklin, Hamilton, Jackson, Jefferson, Madison, Mifflin, Norwich, Plain, Pleasant, Prairie, Sharon, Truro, Blacklick Estates, Huber Ridge, Lincoln Village and Blacklick

A local jeweler helps a young couple who is engagement ring shopping with ring sizing services.

The Best Jewelry Stores in Columbus OH Are the Ones Verified As Safe To Spend With

Jewelry stores in Columbus OH bearing The Prime Buyer's Report Top Ten symbol are those jewelers proven by our independent research to have passed the Top Ten requirements for value and honesty, who use only employees legal to work in the U.S., and for whom our staff has called previous clients to verify high satisfaction with the value received for the sale of new jewelry in Columbus OH, including engagement rings, diamond rings, wedding bands, custom jewelry design, jewelry repair, watch repair, and more.

You deserve the best new jewelry and the best customer care while making your decision and after buying. Choose local jewelers and jewelry stores certified as Prime Buyer's Top Ten.

Updated November 04, 2016

The TOP 10 Jewelry Stores in Columbus OH

The TOP 10 Jewelry Stores in Columbus OH

Leo Alfred Jewelers

  • Leo Alfred Jewelers Profile
  • Leo Alfred Jewelers Scorecard
  • Leo Alfred Jewelers Reviews
  • Leo Alfred Jewelers Photos
  • Leo Alfred Jewelers Brands
  • Leo Alfred Jewelers Articles
  • Leo Alfred Jewelers Offers
(614) 889-5888
4115 W Dublin Granville Rd
Dublin, OH 43017

Areas Served: Franklin County OH, Columbus OH, Dublin OH, Jackson OH, Westerville…
Services: diamond earrings, pendants, gemstones, engagement rings, wedding bands

Winston Wilson Jewelers

  • Winston Wilson Jewelers Profile
  • Winston Wilson Jewelers Scorecard
  • Winston Wilson Jewelers Reviews
  • Winston Wilson Jewelers Photos
  • Winston Wilson Jewelers Brands
  • Winston Wilson Jewelers Articles
  • Winston Wilson Jewelers Offers
(614) 464-3227
300 S High St
Columbus, OH 43215

Areas Served: Mifflin OH, Grove City OH, Franklin County, Jackson OH, Columbus…
Services: cameos, tennis bracelets, class rings, navel rings, white gold jewelry,…

Swarovski

  • Swarovski Profile
  • Swarovski Scorecard
  • Swarovski Reviews
  • Swarovski Photos
  • Swarovski Brands
  • Swarovski Articles
  • Swarovski Offers
(614) 342-6035
4054 the Strand W
Columbus, OH 43219

Areas Served: Westerville OH, Franklin County Ohio, Columbus OH, Mifflin OH, Dublin…
Services: fine jewelry sales, diamond rings, engagement rings, wedding rings, custom…

Tiffany & Co

  • Tiffany & Co Profile
  • Tiffany & Co Scorecard
  • Tiffany & Co Reviews
  • Tiffany & Co Photos
  • Tiffany & Co Brands
  • Tiffany & Co Articles
  • Tiffany & Co Offers
(614) 934-2835
4140 the Strand
Columbus, OH 43219

Areas Served: Columbus OH, Grove City OH, Franklin County, Westerville OH, Dublin…
Services: local jewelry store, custom jewelry designers, tennis bracelets, jewelry repair

Argo & Lehne Jewelers

  • Argo & Lehne Jewelers Profile
  • Argo & Lehne Jewelers Scorecard
  • Argo & Lehne Jewelers Reviews
  • Argo & Lehne Jewelers Photos
  • Argo & Lehne Jewelers Brands
  • Argo & Lehne Jewelers Articles
  • Argo & Lehne Jewelers Offers
(614) 457-6261
3100 Tremont Rd # 100
Upper Arlington, OH 43221

Areas Served: Franklin County, Grove City OH, Grove City OH, Jackson OH,…
Services: gemstones & diamonds in princess cut, marquis cut, radiant cut,…

Diamonds & Designs By None

  • Diamonds & Designs By None Profile
  • Diamonds & Designs By None Scorecard
  • Diamonds & Designs By None Reviews
  • Diamonds & Designs By None Photos
  • Diamonds & Designs By None Brands
  • Diamonds & Designs By None Articles
  • Diamonds & Designs By None Offers
(614) 471-9339
970 N Hamilton Rd
Gahanna, OH 43230

Areas Served: Columbus Ohio, Franklin County Ohio, Jackson OH, Dublin OH, Reynoldsburg…
Services: fine jewelry incl. wedding bands, promise rings, engagement rings, ring…

JB Robinson Jewelers

  • JB Robinson Jewelers Profile
  • JB Robinson Jewelers Scorecard
  • JB Robinson Jewelers Reviews
  • JB Robinson Jewelers Photos
  • JB Robinson Jewelers Brands
  • JB Robinson Jewelers Articles
  • JB Robinson Jewelers Offers
(614) 864-2200
2722 Eastland Mall
Columbus, OH 43232

Areas Served: Franklin County, Westerville OH, Columbus OH, Jackson OH, Reynoldsburg OH,…
Services: fine jewelers for silver necklaces, gold necklaces, diamond rings, ring…

Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers

  • Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers Profile
  • Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers Scorecard
  • Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers Reviews
  • Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers Photos
  • Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers Brands
  • Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers Articles
  • Ashcroft & Oak Jewelers Offers
(614) 888-7888
1500 Polaris Pkwy # 2110
Columbus, OH 43240

Areas Served: Dublin OH, Franklin County, Mifflin OH, Columbus OH, Gahanna OH,…
Services: cut diamonds, resizing rings, diamond jewelry, diamond rings, gold jewelry

Rogers Jewelers

  • Rogers Jewelers Profile
  • Rogers Jewelers Scorecard
  • Rogers Jewelers Reviews
  • Rogers Jewelers Photos
  • Rogers Jewelers Brands
  • Rogers Jewelers Articles
  • Rogers Jewelers Offers
(614) 786-1630
1500 Polaris Pkwy # 2196
Columbus, OH 43240

Areas Served: Pickerington OH, Columbus OH, Whitehall OH, Dublin OH, Grove City…
Services: local jewelers for engagement rings, wedding bands, diamond rings

The Best Jewelry Stores in Columbus OH Are the Ones Verified As Safe To Spend With

Top of page